Assignment details:
- Read 5 Wall Streett Journal articles published between May 18 and June 26.
- For each article, write 2 paragraphs: (1) articles summary; (2) your thoughts and/or analysis of the issues discussed in the article.
- For each article, clearly indicate article title and publication date.
- Put your write-up for all 5 articles into a single Word or PDF document.
- At the end of your document, create a reference list with article title, author, and link to the original article.
How to choose articles:
The articles must be related to investments, so please avoid general news articles, political news, culture news, opinion pieces not related to finance, even news about particular companies or industries unless you can make an explicit connection to how the news affect investors. Suitable topics include financial markets, financial institutions, stocks, stock indexes, bonds, interest rates, inflation, mutual funds, ETFs, exchange rates, commodities, macroeconomic indicators, investor expectations, consumer confidence, IPOs, volatility. Use your best judgment in determining whether a particular article fits the scope of our class. I especially welcome articles about the effect that the spread of the coronavirus is having on financial markets in the US and the US economy.
What to write:
In the summary paragraph, concisely provide the necessary background information and then summarize the main points that the author is making. In the analysis paragraph, you can focus on a few of the following approaches: challenge the assumptions that the author is making, challenge the validity of the author’s conclusions, relate the author’s argument to the concepts learned in the class, generalize the conclusions of the author beyond the scope of the article, ask follow-up and what-if questions related to the article. As our course progresses, you are expected to increasingly link what you have read to the concepts we have covered in the class.
INVESTMENTS: WSJ REPORT EXAMPLE Article Reviews by Adam Bates, UT Finance Major Article 1: Stocks Gain as U.S. Weighs Restarting Economy (April 14, 2020) This article spoke about how stock prices rose on 4/12/2020 around 3% collectively. The Dow rose 2.4% S&P rose 3.1% and Nasdaq Composite gained 323.32 points, or 3.9%. This was around the news that many experts believed that the peak of the COVID-19 has passed and the economy is becoming more concentrated on rebuilding. At that time the Dow was still down 19% from its all-time-high despite this gain. Earning season is also coming up and many investors are worried about what will be uncovered during these announcements. However, many investors also believe that stock prices are already discounted, and the earnings estimates have already been taken into account with the current price of the stocks. Financial Institutions such as JP Morgan Chase have already reported 70% earnings drop due to the potential losses they face on their loans to their clients. Their stock however has only dropped 2.7%. An interesting quote I found in this article is from Shawn Snyder, a head of investment strategist at Citi Personal Wealth Management. “I think the market is almost willing to ignore 2020 and is focused on the returns of 2021, when the virus is more likely to be under control.” Could it be that the efficient market hypothesis is false in this situation due to human emotion? In chapter 8 we learned about the efficient market hypothesis that states prices of securities fully reflect the available information. When reading this article, I felt almost the opposite of what should happen is happening. During this time there is of course a lot of uncertainty, but as an investor I would expect a larger premium due to the risk of the uncertainty, but with the stock prices rising there is little to no upside within the market for the next three months. I believe that currently the human emotion of hope is getting in the way of these stocks getting priced effectively. Shawn Snyder’s quote pointed it out what I believe fairly well. Investors are willing to put up with these losses in 2020 in hopes of growth to come one year from now in 2021. I personally don’t believe that stock prices should be rising just yet as there are still a lot of situations to play out. There is a possibility of a second wave of infections when states re-open, as well as larger cuts in earnings that are to be reported soon. Article 2: When Your Fund Beats the Market, Ask: Which Market? (April 24, 2020) One of the topics touched on in chapter 4 was mutual funds. This article talks about one specific fund and the fund manager. Putnam launched a fund named Capital Spectrum and named David Glancy as the fund manager. Capital Spectrum was a “go-anywhere” fund meaning that it was able to buy anything that the manager found attractive. This type of fund is usually a good bet depending on who the manager is because the fund has no limitations. This fund has the capabilities to even dip into foreign markets if it seems profitable. As we learned in chapter 4 this fund had its own unique fee structure. Glancy would earn a small % (less than 1) of the money managed in the fund as a base. But he would also make a bonus if the fund beats a benchmark. The benchmark for Capital Spectrum was 50-50 blend of the S&P 500 and the JP Morgan High Yield index which consisted of low-rated corporate bonds. From May 2009 to October 2013 the Class A shares of the fund earned around 24% annually compared to the benchmark at 18% and the S&P 500 at 18.4%. These high gains attracted new investors to the fund and soon its assets were around $11 billion. It wasn’t before long that shares were losing 9% while the S&P was still gaining 14.4% annually. In 2015 shareholders withdrew a total of $1.5 billion and then a total of $7 billion from 2016 to the end of last year. Putnam has had to pay about $5 million back into the fund in rebates due to its lack of performance against the benchmark. I am both a fan of mutual funds as well as the fulcrum (performance based) fees that this article talked about. To begin I think a mutual fund is a great way for an investor to diversify his portfolio. By buying a single share you are effectively spreading your eggs out into multiple baskets. One thing this article brings to light is how an investor must know what the fund is doing. There is a large difference between a mutual funds that invests into stocks and one that invests into bonds. Its important to know what type of financial assets your fund is holding and from what sector of the economy. Putnam’s fund was hard to keep an eye on because it was not specifically designed for anything in particular. Fulcrum fees was another great topic that the article brought up. I believe that managers should be rewarded on high returns as well as being punished for losses. This way it keeps the manager wanting the same thing as the shareholders, large returns. The benchmark in this case was clearly bogus because it used half of the benchmark assets in bonds and no where near 50% of the fund’s assets were in bonds at all. We all know the stocks have a tendency to yield higher returns than bonds, so it was not that big of a deal to beat their benchmark. Having a real benchmark though will make the stockholder believe in the fund managers more because they are able to compare their performance to that of some close. I believe when shareholders get to see when the manager does good that they actually won’t mind paying out the fees. Article 3: Wall Street Explores Changes to Circuit Breakers After Coronavirus Crash (April 15, 2020) This article talks about a mechanism that is used to help protect investors from large losses. A circuit breaker happens if the S&P loses 7% then it will trigger a 15-minute halt where all trading is stopped on the market. Next if the market falls 13% it will have another 15-minute cool off time. If the S&P decreases by 20% then the market will be shut down for the rest of the day. The breaks are meant for investors to have time to take in all the information that is being sent their way. The break also allows investors to have a better reaction compared to a knee-jerk reaction they might have if they were not given the time to think about their actions. I believe that these rules and mechanisms are good and help make the market a safer place for all investors. Circuit breakers helped a lot during the 2010 flash crash, and they were still improved after that. A lot of what happens when the market is crashing is two types of sell offs. The first is computer based and the algorithm tells it to start selling. Then there is emotional selling where investors fell unsafe and try to exit the market by selling the assets. Again, with time to adjust the algorithm as well as understand the situation more to feel safe will help in these down turns. Article 4: Treasuries Rally as Oil Price Drop Leaves Investors Jittery (April 21, 2020) This article talked about how between what is going on with the corona virus as well as the oil market hitting all time lows U.S. Treasuries are Rallying. According to the article the yield on a 10-year dropped to 0.571% from 0.625% while the 30-year has fallen to 1.162% from 1.234%. The yield on the 5-year not actually hit a unprecedented low of 0.304%. Another point that the article brings up is that the sharp drop in oil prices is also dragging down inflation expectations. To gage these expectations the article used the five-year, five-year forward U.S. inflation swap. The oil prices have changed the perception of many economist about how the global economy is doing and where it is headed in the future. This article also touches on foreign bonds, specifically those of the eurozone. The reason is many investors believe that the ministers of those countries will fail in trying to agree on a common debt-issuance program. The perk of that program would be that it would share the burden of shielding economies across EU members from the rescission. However, there is practically no way that it will pass because countries like Italy, which has been hit the hardest, will want to issue more debt than others. And those countries who do not want to issue debt will either be burdened with Italy’s debt of stop Italy from issuing it. I think right now is a very interesting time to be looking at bonds, specifically government bonds. The reason is, with COVID-19 countries are being forced to put out very large stimulus packages to make sure everyone can eat and to make sure that when it is over people will still have jobs to go back to. But where is all that money coming from? In a separate article I read it spoke about how states are now running on larger deficits because they cannot make any money through the income tax. In order to make sure all is provided for the government will have to issue more debt. With a flood of new debt to the market, yields will have to be higher in order to attract investors, but at the same time investors are already interested because is a safer asset to own compared to others in this time. Also, oil is making it a much safer bet to buy in U.S. treasuries because they will be able to beat the inflation rate. I think the foreign bonds are also interesting to think about however it is mostly political when it comes to the EU. Article 5: The Reach for Yield Survives Coronavirus Market Shock (April 27, 2020) In this article the authors, Gunjan Banerji and Julia-Ambra Verline, speak about how amidst the crisis bond managers and investors are still searching for high yielding bonds. The specific sector of bonds that is really creating interest for those managers and investors are the asset-backed securities. Investors have been faced with the risky stock market and falling yields on government bonds, but they still want to have a good return. Despite economic conditions being rough and combined with a fall of consumer spending the demand for bonds backed by U.S. auto loans has outstripped supply in recent days. Dell Technologies has also sold roughly $1.1 billion in debt which backed by leases on equipment to big and small companies. Investors really seemed to like that debt offering during this time. March and February monthly issuance of structured retail products are both higher than they have been in the past five years. However, according to JPMorgan Chase & Co. only $55 billion in asset-backed securities has been issued, which is down from $77 billion over the same period last year. If I were a bond manager, I would be jumping on these asset-backed securities as well. In my opinion they are safer than normal corporate debt because they actually have something to lean on and as an investor you know what to track in order to sell the bond before it loose its value. One thing that I do not disagree with in this article is how investors are buying up subprime auto debt. This type of debt is typically to a riskier borrower with lower credit scores. Especially now, during the COVID-19 crisis, it is not a safe asset to have. The people paying these loans might be the same ones that are losing their jobs. About 7.5% of the loans have received a payment extension in March which is up 1% from February. I don’t believe that the number of people who need extensions will go down anytime soon and soon defaults will happen. If I were in the bond market, I would definitely be picking up some asset based with high yields such as the Dell issuance. I suppose the textbook would describe me as an active bond manager.\ References McCabe, C., 2020. Stocks Gain As U.S. Weighs Restarting Economy. [online] The Wall Street Journal. Available at: [Accessed 13 May 2020]. Zweig, J., 2020. When Your Fund Beats The Market, Ask: Which Market?. [online] The Wall Street Journal. Available at: [Accessed 13 May 2020]. Lim, A., 2020. Wall Street Explores Changes To Circuit Breakers After Coronavirus Crash. [online] The Wall Street Journal. Available at: [Accessed 13 May 2020]. Davies, A., 2020. Treasuries Rally As Oil Price Drop Leaves Investors Jittery. [online] The Wall Street Journal. Available at: [Accessed 13 May 2020]. Verlaine, G., 2020. The Reach For Yield Survives Coronavirus Market Shock. [online] The Wall Street Journal. Available at: [Accessed 13 May 2020]. INVESTMENTS: WSJ REPORT EXAMPLE Article Reviews by Adam Bates, UT Finance Major Article 1: Stocks Gain as U.S. Weighs Restarting Economy (April 14, 2020) This article spoke about how stock prices rose on 4/12/2020 around 3% collectively. The Dow rose 2.4% S&P rose 3.1% and Nasdaq Composite gained 323.32 points, or 3.9%. This was around the news that many experts believed that the peak of the COVID-19 has passed and the economy is becoming more concentrated on rebuilding. At that time the Dow was still down 19% from its all-time-high despite this gain. Earning season is also coming up and many investors are worried about what will be uncovered during these announcements. However, many investors also believe that stock prices are already discounted, and the earnings estimates have already been taken into account with the current price of the stocks. Financial Institutions such as JP Morgan Chase have already reported 70% earnings drop due to the potential losses they face on their loans to their clients. Their stock however has only dropped 2.7%. An interesting quote I found in this article is from Shawn Snyder, a head of investment strategist at Citi Personal Wealth Management. “I think the market is almost willing to ignore 2020 and is focused on the returns of 2021, when the virus is more likely to be under control.” Could it be that the efficient market hypothesis is false in this situation due to human emotion? In chapter 8 we learned about the efficient market hypothesis that states prices of securities fully reflect the available information. When reading this article, I felt almost the opposite of what should happen is happening. During this time there is of course a lot of uncertainty, but as an investor I would expect a larger premium due to the risk of the uncertainty, but with the stock prices rising there is little to no upside within the market for the next three months. I believe that currently the human emotion of hope is getting in the way of these stocks getting priced effectively. Shawn Snyder’s quote pointed it out what I believe fairly well. Investors are willing to put up with these losses in 2020 in hopes of growth to come one year from now in 2021. I personally don’t believe that stock prices should be rising just yet as there are still a lot of situations to play out. There is a possibility of a second wave of infections when states re-open, as well as larger cuts in earnings that are to be reported soon. Article 2: When Your Fund Beats the Market, Ask: Which Market? (April 24, 2020) One of the topics touched on in chapter 4 was mutual funds. This article talks about one specific fund and the fund manager. Putnam launched a fund named Capital Spectrum and named David Glancy as the fund manager. Capital Spectrum was a “go-anywhere” fund meaning that it was able to buy anything that the manager found attractive. This type of fund is usually a good bet depending on who the manager is because the fund has no limitations. This fund has the capabilities to even dip into foreign markets if it seems profitable. As we learned in chapter 4 this fund had its own unique fee structure. Glancy would earn a small % (less than 1) of the money managed in the fund as a base. But he would also make a bonus if the fund beats a benchmark. The benchmark for Capital Spectrum was 50-50 blend of the S&P 500 and the JP Morgan High Yield index which consisted of low-rated corporate bonds. From May 2009 to October 2013 the Class A shares of the fund earned around 24% annually compared to the benchmark at 18% and the S&P 500 at 18.4%. These high gains attracted new investors to the fund and soon its assets were around $11 billion. It wasn’t before long that shares were losing 9% while the S&P was still gaining 14.4% annually. In 2015 shareholders withdrew a total of $1.5 billion and then a total of $7 billion from 2016 to the end of last year. Putnam has had to pay about $5 million back into the fund in rebates due to its lack of performance against the benchmark. I am both a fan of mutual funds as well as the fulcrum (performance based) fees that this article talked about. To begin I think a mutual fund is a great way for an investor to diversify his portfolio. By buying a single share you are effectively spreading your eggs out into multiple baskets. One thing this article brings to light is how an investor must know what the fund is doing. There is a large difference between a mutual funds that invests into stocks and one that invests into bonds. Its important to know what type of financial assets your fund is holding and from what sector of the economy. Putnam’s fund was hard to keep an eye on because it was not specifically designed for anything in particular. Fulcrum fees was another great topic that the article brought up. I believe that managers should be rewarded on high returns as well as being punished for losses. This way it keeps the manager wanting the same thing as the shareholders, large returns. The benchmark in this case was clearly bogus because it used half of the benchmark assets in bonds and no where near 50% of the fund’s assets were in bonds at all. We all know the stocks have a tendency to yield higher returns than bonds, so it was not that big of a deal to beat their benchmark. Having a real benchmark though will make the stockholder believe in the fund managers more because they are able to compare their performance to that of some close. I believe when shareholders get to see when the manager does good that they actually won’t mind paying out the fees. Article 3: Wall Street Explores Changes to Circuit Breakers After Coronavirus Crash (April 15, 2020) This article talks about a mechanism that is used to help protect investors from large losses. A circuit breaker happens if the S&P loses 7% then it will trigger a 15-minute halt where all trading is stopped on the market. Next if the market falls 13% it will have another 15-minute cool off time. If the S&P decreases by 20% then the market will be shut down for the rest of the day. The breaks are meant for investors to have time to take in all the information that is being sent their way. The break also allows investors to have a better reaction compared to a knee-jerk reaction they might have if they were not given the time to think about their actions. I believe that these rules and mechanisms are good and help make the market a safer place for all investors. Circuit breakers helped a lot during the 2010 flash crash, and they were still improved after that. A lot of what happens when the market is crashing is two types of sell offs. The first is computer based and the algorithm tells it to start selling. Then there is emotional selling where investors fell unsafe and try to exit the market by selling the assets. Again, with time to adjust the algorithm as well as understand the situation more to feel safe will help in these down turns. Article 4: Treasuries Rally as Oil Price Drop Leaves Investors Jittery (April 21, 2020) This article talked about how between what is going on with the corona virus as well as the oil market hitting all time lows U.S. Treasuries are Rallying. According to the article the yield on a 10-year dropped to 0.571% from 0.625% while the 30-year has fallen to 1.162% from 1.234%. The yield on the 5-year not actually hit a unprecedented low of 0.304%. Another point that the article brings up is that the sharp drop in oil prices is also dragging down inflation expectations. To gage these expectations the article used the five-year, five-year forward U.S. inflation swap. The oil prices have changed the perception of many economist about how the global economy is doing and where it is headed in the future. This article also touches on foreign bonds, specifically those of the eurozone. The reason is many investors believe that the ministers of those countries will fail in trying to agree on a common debt-issuance program. The perk of that program would be that it would share the burden of shielding economies across EU members from the rescission. However, there is practically no way that it will pass because countries like Italy, which has been hit the hardest, will want to issue more debt than others. And those countries who do not want to issue debt will either be burdened with Italy’s debt of stop Italy from issuing it. I think right now is a very interesting time to be looking at bonds, specifically government bonds. The reason is, with COVID-19 countries are being forced to put out very large stimulus packages to make sure everyone can eat and to make sure that when it is over people will still have jobs to go back to. But where is all that money coming from? In a separate article I read it spoke about how states are now running on larger deficits because they cannot make any money through the income tax. In order to make sure all is provided for the government will have to issue more debt. With a flood of new debt to the market, yields will have to be higher in order to attract investors, but at the same time investors are already interested because is a safer asset to own compared to others in this time. Also, oil is making it a much safer bet to buy in U.S. treasuries because they will be able to beat the inflation rate. I think the foreign bonds are also interesting to think about however it is mostly political when it comes to the EU. Article 5: The Reach for Yield Survives Coronavirus Market Shock (April 27, 2020) In this article the authors, Gunjan Banerji and Julia-Ambra Verline, speak about how amidst the crisis bond managers and investors are still searching for high yielding bonds. The specific sector of bonds that is really creating interest for those managers and investors are the asset-backed securities. Investors have been faced with the risky stock market and falling yields on government bonds, but they still want to have a good return. Despite economic conditions being rough and combined with a fall of consumer spending the demand for bonds backed by U.S. auto loans has outstripped supply in recent days. Dell Technologies has also sold roughly $1.1 billion in debt which backed by leases on equipment to big and small companies. Investors really seemed to like that debt offering during this time. March and February monthly issuance of structured retail products are both higher than they have been in the past five years. However, according to JPMorgan Chase & Co. only $55 billion in asset-backed securities has been issued, which is down from $77 billion over the same period last year. If I were a bond manager, I would be jumping on these asset-backed securities as well. In my opinion they are safer than normal corporate debt because they actually have something to lean on and as an investor you know what to track in order to sell the bond before it loose its value. One thing that I do not disagree with in this article is how investors are buying up subprime auto debt. This type of debt is typically to a riskier borrower with lower credit scores. Especially now, during the COVID-19 crisis, it is not a safe asset to have. The people paying these loans might be the same ones that are losing their jobs. About 7.5% of the loans have received a payment extension in March which is up 1% from February. I don’t believe that the number of people who need extensions will go down anytime soon and soon defaults will happen. If I were in the bond market, I would definitely be picking up some asset based with high yields such as the Dell issuance. I suppose the textbook would describe me as an active bond manager.\ References McCabe, C., 2020. Stocks Gain As U.S. Weighs Restarting Economy. [online] The Wall Street Journal. Available at: [Accessed 13 May 2020]. Zweig, J., 2020. When Your Fund Beats The Market, Ask: Which Market?. [online] The Wall Street Journal. Available at: [Accessed 13 May 2020]. Lim, A., 2020. Wall Street Explores Changes To Circuit Breakers After Coronavirus Crash. [online] The Wall Street Journal. Available at: [Accessed 13 May 2020]. Davies, A., 2020. Treasuries Rally As Oil Price Drop Leaves Investors Jittery. [online] The Wall Street Journal. Available at: [Accessed 13 May 2020]. Verlaine, G., 2020. The Reach For Yield Survives Coronavirus Market Shock. [online] The Wall Street Journal. Available at: [Accessed 13 May 2020].
Purchase answer to see full attachment